Censorship is defined by Encyclopedia Britannica as an “Act of changing or suppressing speech or writing that is considered subversive of the common good”. Wikipedia, the online encyclopedia says “Censorship is the removal or withholding of information from the public by a controlling group or body. Typically censorship is done by governments, religious groups, or the mass media“
In the minds of most Heavy metal fans their music has long been the whipping boy for the censors in our society. From Ozzy Osbourne, Iron Maiden, W.A.S.P. Guns n Roses and now Marilyn Manson and Rob Zombie, all have attracted the unwanted attention of the censors, In fact it would be a struggle to find a heavy metal band that hasn’t been under their scrutiny at some point in time. They also think the reason behind the censorship of heavy metal by those in control is to silence any message (through song lyrics) that may encourage people to stand up for themselves as individuals, to make their own decisions in life, and to constantly question authority.
The rebellious message behind heavy metal music is a real thorn in the sides of those that want us to all be “yes men” and as such makes the heavy metal genre a prime target for attack by people with the influence and power to do something about it. The attitude behind heavy metal music is about making those in authority earn the respect that they want blindly given to them by the public. This makes these people in authority, be they politicians, parent’s groups etc, very uncomfortable because they often lack the substance to ever really earn that respect for themselves. The motivation for censoring heavy metal is part of an attempt to force respect for authority, this is the opinion of the average everyday heavy metal fan.
However your average everyday censor will have a different view, they will say they are merely trying to protect and shelter the youth of today from offensive and harmful content. They will point to the supposed connections between heavy metal music and Satanism, using the Ozzy Osbourne song “Mr. Crowley” as an example. They may also use the case of the West Memphis Three as proof that the influence of so called Satanic music can lead to the moral decay of the young members of our society.
On the surface the West Memphis Three case seems pretty cut and dryed, on the 6th May 1993 three eight-year-old boys; James M. Moore, Steven E. Branch and Christopher M. Byers were found mutilated and murdered and submerged in a muddy creek near Robin Hood Hills in West Memphis, Arkansas, they had been stripped naked and were hogtied with their own shoelaces, local newspapers stated the killers had been caught. The police assured the public that the three teenagers in custody were definitely responsible for these horrible crimes, Damien Echols, Jessie Misskelley and Jason Baldwin.
What was their overwhelming evidence you may ask? Police questioned one of the boys, Jessie Misskelley, who’s mentally handicapped, for twelve hours without prior parental consent and without counsel present until he confessed, later that day, Misskelley tried to recant the confession but it was too late, the three were arrested on the 3rd June 1993 and were successfully convicted in early 1994. Although there was no actual evidence to speak of the prosecution presented the fact that the three listened to “satanic” music, had dyed black hair and wore gothic clothing, all as proof that they had killed three boys that they had never met and had no motive to kill, also no murder weapon was ever found. Echols was sentenced to death, Baldwin received life without parole, and Misskelley got life plus 40.
Rumors of the existence of Satanic groups in this dominantly Baptist community had persisted for decades. Details of their so called exploits were common knowledge although there was never and has never been any proof of any murders actually having taken place in the past. From the first moment that the arrests were made up until they were tried and convicted, local newspapers fed the community’s blood-lust, with fantastical stories of so called Satanic abominations appearing on a regular basis
More than thirteen years after these sentences were handed down, the three young men (Echols, 31, Misskelley, 29 and Baldwin, 29) continue to proclaim their innocence and are persevering in their attempts to have new trials granted. This in itself is not unusual. There are many guilty men who have succeeded in tying up the legal system in the process of appeals for as many as fifteen years. What is unusual in this case is that they are not alone in proclaiming their innocence.
Thousands of American citizens are convinced that Jessie, Jason and Damien were wrongly tried and convicted and are now lending their support to the fight for justice. Everyday this support is growing and now includes many criminal and legal experts who are throwing the weight of their knowledge and experience behind the three boys.
Damien Echols claims that he was found guilty long before the trial began because he was considered weird by many in the community, having practiced the Wicca religion and listened to the music of supposedly Satanic groups such as “Metallica.” Jason believes he was found guilty by association. Jessie claims that his confession was coerced, claiming he had told police whatever they had wanted him to so that they would let him go.
My point is that the way the people and the law enforcement in that town thought, the way they treated those three teenage boys and their general opinion on the subculture known as heavy metal is the reason that very same type of music is the most susceptible to the censors, people want to suppress what they don’t understand or label it as Echols himself says as “weird”.